- personally responsible citizens
- participatory citizens
- social justice oriented citizens
Students who are personally responsible would not have contributed to the negative environment in Miss Starbuck or Mr. Kirk's classrooms. This is a basic element of citizenship, knowing and following the rules. A lot of character education fits into this mode. In Miss Starbuck's case, she may not have even established the rules for her students and clearly did not make them aware of the Acceptable Use Policy. We can't assume that students should know what to do, especially adolescents who are still developmentally working on their judgment.
Participatory citizens are those who take an active role in citizenship. They vote, follow the news, serve on a jury, write letters to the editor, report crimes to the police, attend public meetings and actively participate in the civil society in many other ways. Participatory digital citizens would be the ones who might tell the teacher that something was going on. They may also be the kinds of citizens who act together to speak up and try to make the cyber space a place of civil discourse. Here students feel some responsibility for the common space not just their space. Persuading students that this is not "snitching" and that it is about building something better is hard. Adolescents need safe opportunities to try these behaviors out to deliberate ideas and to see things beyond absolutes of right and wrong Poor Mr. Kirk made some bad choices by taking away technology - the learning ended right there.
Social Justice oriented citizens seek out injustices and work to correct those wrongs in society. These are students who would use the available technologies to try to shape the public debate #blacklivesmatter or #educolor are some examples. It is possible that some of Mr. McFly's students are drawing comments from social activists but we want to help students learn how not to be a troll also. Comment but do so responsibly.
I like the idea of teaching students how to be civic minded is a ultimately a better way to manage technology than having a list of do's and don'ts. I read an article about a curriculum for middle schools called Cyber Civics. It didn't sound too intrusive and seemed to have a good success rate so I'd be willing to give that a try to get us to personally responsible citizens.
Most of my own oh-oh moments seem to be when students are using their own devices - mostly phones. Many of the "distraction" issues - texting, snap chat, etc. I treat like passing notes - a routine classroom management issue. The more serious issues (impending fights, the kid watching porn on his phone) require a higher level of intervention but not being able to "see" the incident makes taking action tougher on a personal device rather than a school issued device.
To help with making sure I stay within the acceptable uses of technology I'll be sure to vet new apps as suggested in the resources. I also think it would be helpful to build Chromebook routines (just like other classroom procedures - bathroom, turning in assignments, locker). Those will probably include assigned Chromebooks, modes of operation and signals about when we are an are not using the Chromebooks. Since we'll have access to devices for school, this should also make it easier to have a "cell phone box" or to insist that they be turned off and put away, reducing the hazards I've had in the past.

"How not to be a troll." Ha!
ReplyDeleteYour discussion of the lack of right and wrong absolutes resonated with me. As well as your connections to social justice and cyber civics.
ReplyDeleteYour three models of citizenship should be the foundation for all teachers and students engaged in online activities. I too like the tip about the Cyber Civics curriculum.
ReplyDeleteIf you figure out how to do this... "cell phone box" or to insist that they be turned off and put away, reducing the hazards I've had in the past.... I'd LOVE to hear how it works :)
ReplyDelete